Public School Uniforms: The Pros and Cons for Your Child
The prevalence of uniforms in public schools continues to rise in the United States, as parents and school administrators exert efforts to keep our schools safe environments.According to the National Center for Education Statistics, nearly 20% of all public schools have adopted uniform mandates, and this trend continues to accelerate.Even with these compelling statistics, however, there are other statistics that argue that uniforms are not as beneficial as school administrators and parents are encouraged to believe.Opponents cite research that shows a lack of individualism and comfort among students, working to actually decrease student learning and success.Thus, the question still remains: are public school uniforms good for your child?
Student Appearance: Distraction or Free Expression?
First and foremost, many administrators claim that students are not as distracted by how they look, and therefore, spend more time learning at school. This allows students to focus more upon their schoolwork, rather than social appearances.Furthermore,the socioeconomic differences present among students are minimized when all students must wear the same school uniforms, no longer feeling the pressure to “fit in” with the right clothing choices. Opponents argue that uniforms may not be comfortable for all students, which will limit learning as students worry about their appearance. Children, especially those in middle and high school, are constantly concerned about their appearance, and wearing a school uniform will not alleviate this concern.
Schools Need Solutions
According to school-reported statistics and theSchool Administrator,the mandate of uniforms on campuses has reduced tardiness, skipped classes, suspensions, and discipline referrals among students. With uniforms, a more professional tone is set in school, encouraging students to take their studies more seriously.Some people argue focusing on uniforms takes attention away from finding genuine solutions to these problems in education. More substantive improvements to public education could be achieved with smaller class sizes, tightened security, increased parental involvement, improved facilities, and other measures.
A Concern for Safety
Uniforms at school also reduce the prevalence of violence, which is a major concern for many public schools. Additionally, uniforms reduce the prevalence of “cliques” and gangs on school campuses as students are required to only wear specific colors and uniform pieces. “You’ll have the popular girls and the nerdier girls with or without the uniforms,” says Daisy Kong, who graduated from a parochial school that required uniforms. On the contrary, there is little evidence that uniforms provide solutions to this problem. David L. Brunsma, PhD, Professor of Sociology at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University (Virginia Tech), co-authored a study that analyzed a national sample of 10th graders and found "no effectsof uniforms on absenteeism, behavioral problems (fights, suspensions, etc.), or substance use on campus.”
Real World Effects
The opponents of public school uniforms argue that uniforms stifle a student’s need for self-expression. Controlling the socialization process could harm the student as an adult, as they are not prepared for the real world, where they will indeed by judged by their appearances. However, Rachel Berman, who graduated from a private high school that required uniforms, says, “the uniforms contributed to a more sedate, professional feel that I think made it easier to focus on school.” Moreover she adds that, “there were days in college where I actually found myself missing my uniform because I didn’t know what to wear and would spend 30-40 minutes shuffling through my closet.”
Even Parents Are Unresolved
Pro-uniform parents say now that kids are getting mugged for their designer clothes and expensive sneakers, school uniforms seem a safer alternative to many. Whereas some parents believe that uniforms are more cost-effective than purchasing the latest stylish clothes, other parents argue that the cost of uniforms is steep.Many parents argue that uniforms are not economical as they must purchase both a school wardrobe and a casual wardrobe as children do not want or may not be permitted to wear their uniform clothes outside of school. Many schools have an “opt-out” clause for students who choose not to wear the uniform, and most provide free uniforms to those who cannot afford them. “My two children attend a school with a lower school uniform and I love it,” says Marcia Turner. “Having a specific set of clothes the kids must choose from makes outfit selection a no-brainer. No more fights or discussions about what to wear since that decision has virtually been made for them.”