/ PSM 1 SUPERVISOR EVALUATION RUBRIC
FACULTY OF MECHANICAL & MANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
CRITERIA / 5 - EXCELLENT / 4 - VERY GOOD / 3 - GOOD / 2 – FAIR / 1 – POOR
I) REPORT ASSESSMENT(45%)
A) INTRODUCTION / Consists of information regarding project background and the following:
  • Project justification,
  • Preliminary finding,
  • Flow & Organization
presented in precise and well organized structure / Consists of information regarding project background and the following:
  • Project justification,
  • Preliminary finding,
  • Flow & Organization
presented in well organized structure / Consists of information regarding project background and TWO of the following:
  • Project justification,
  • Preliminary finding,
  • Flow & Organization
which correctly stated / Consists of information regarding project background and ONE of the following:
  • Project justification,
  • Preliminary finding,
  • Flow & Organization
which correctly stated / Consists of information regarding project background and ONE of the following:
  • Project justification,
  • Preliminary finding,
  • Flow & Organization
which poorly stated
B) PROBLEM STATEMENT / Identify the problem and well defined explanation, consists of parameter involved and the following:
  • Characteristic,
  • Effect,
  • Preliminary suggestion
  • Contribution of the work
presented in precise and well organized structure / Identify the problem and well defined explanation, consists of parameter involved and the following:
  • Characteristic,
  • Effect,
  • Preliminary suggestion
  • Contribution of the work
presented in well organized structure / Identify the problem and well defined explanation, consists of parameter involved and THREE of the following:
  • Characteristic,
  • Effect,
  • Preliminary suggestion
  • Contribution of the work
which correctly stated / Identify the problem and well defined explanation, consists of parameter involved and TWO of the following:
  • Characteristic,
  • Effect,
  • Preliminary suggestion
  • Contribution of the work
which correctly stated / Identify the problem and well defined explanation, consists of parameter involved and ONE of the following:
  • Characteristic,
  • Effect,
  • Preliminary suggestion
  • Contribution of the work
which correctly stated
C) OBJECTIVESCOPE / Objective and scope consists of the following:
  • Purpose,
  • Well defined parameter,
  • limitation
  • work/activity/tool involved
presented in precise and well organized structure / Objective and scope consists of the following:
  • Purpose,
  • Well defined parameter,
  • limitation
  • work/activity/tool involved
presented in well organized structure / Objective and scope consists of THREE of the following:
  • Purpose,
  • Well defined parameter,
  • limitation
  • work/activity/tool involved
which correctly stated / Objective and scope consists of TWO of the following:
  • Purpose,
  • Well defined parameter,
  • limitation
  • work/activity/tool involved
which correctly stated / Objective and scope consists of ONE of the following:
  • Purpose,
  • Well defined parameter,
  • limitation
  • work/activity/tool involved
which correctly stated
D) LITERATURE REVIEW & THEORIES / Consists of relevant information regarding previous work, fundamental knowledge and the preliminary theories which are:
  • Referred from more than 5 papers/journals
  • References are quoted correctly
  • Identified the work contribution
  • Flow & Organization
presented in precise and well organized structure / Consists of relevant information regarding previous work, fundamental knowledge and the preliminary theories which are:
  • Referred from at least 5 papers/journals
  • References are quoted correctly
  • Identified the work contribution
  • Flow & Organization
presented in well organized structure / Consists of relevant information regarding previous work, fundamental knowledge and the preliminary theories which are:
  • Referred from at least 4 papers/journals
  • References are quoted correctly
  • Identified the work contribution
  • Flow & Organization
which correctly stated / Consists of relevant information regarding previous work, fundamental knowledge and the preliminary theories which are:
  • Referred from at least 3 papers/journals
  • References are quoted correctly
  • Identified the work contribution
  • Flow & Organization
which correctly stated / Consists of relevant information regarding previous work, fundamental knowledge and the preliminary theories which are:
  • Referred from at least 2 papers/journals
  • References are quoted correctly
  • Identified the work contribution
  • Flow & Organization
which correctly stated
E) METHODOLOGY & GANTT CHART / Consists of detailed information regarding workflow, strategy and approach, and the following:
  • Theories are applied
  • Analytical study
  • Method/tool to be applied
  • Creative and innovative
  • Flow & Organization
presented in precise and well organized structure / Consists of detailed information regarding workflow, strategy and approach, and the following:
  • Theories are applied
  • Analytical study
  • Method/tool to beapplied
  • Creative and innovative
  • Flow & Organization
presented in well organized structure / Consists of detailed information regarding workflow, strategy and approach, and the following:
  • Theories are applied
  • Analytical study
  • Method/tool to be applied
  • Flow & Organization
which correctly stated
/ Consists of detailed information regarding workflow, strategy and approach, and the following:
  • Theories are applied
  • Analytical study
  • Method/tool to be applied
  • Flow & Organization
which fairly stated / Consists of detailed information regarding workflow, strategy and approach, and the following:
  • Theories are applied
  • Analytical study
  • Method/tool to be applied
  • Flow & Organization
which poorly stated
F) EXPECTED RESULT / Expected results are in accordance with the theory and are creatively presented and elaborated in a precise and orderly manner. / Expected results are in accordance with the theory and presented and elaborated in a precise and orderly manner. / Expected results are in accordance with the theory and presented and elaborated in orderly manner. / Expected results are not fully in accordance with the theory. / Expected result is poor and not the same with theory.
G) CONCLUSION / Conclusions are made accordance with the overall process including
  • main goal
  • methods
  • expected result
which are creatively presented in a precise and orderly manner. / Conclusions are made accordance with the overall process including
  • main goal
  • methods
  • expected result
which are presented in an orderly manner. / Conclusions are made accordance with the overall process including TWO of the following
  • main goal
  • methods
  • expected result
which are properly stated. / Conclusions are made accordance with the overall process including ONE of the following
  • main goal
  • methods
  • expected result
which are fairly stated. / Conclusions are poorly stated.
H) REFERENCES /
  • 100 % according to format
  • Well presented and organized
/
  • 100 % according to format
/
  • 80 % according to format
/
  • 50 % according to format
/
  • Poor quality

(II) LOG BOOK ASSESSMENT(30 %) / 5 - EXCELLENT / 4 - VERY GOOD / 3 - GOOD / 2 – FAIR / 1 – POOR
A) FREQUENCY OF COLLECTING DATA /
  • Data and information are updated very frequently
/
  • Data and information are updated frequently
/
  • Data and information are updated less frequently
/
  • Data and information are updated very less frequently
/
  • Data and information are updated very less frequently and limited knowledge

B) RELEVANCE OF INFORMATION /
  • Very relevant
/
  • Relevant
/
  • Quite relevant
/
  • Less relevant
/
  • Least relevant

C) STUDENT DETERMINATION /
  • Good student with proactive and independent
/
  • Good student with proactive and least dependency
/
  • Active student but need to be directed
/
  • Student is always depend on supervisor instruction
/
  • Very minimum effort

1

PSM 1- SUPERVISOR