ST 432 Final Report Scoring Rubric (70 points)
Description of sampling design / 0
Completely unclear / 2
I think you did something in the library / 4
With a lot of work, I think I figured it out / 6
Some misuse of terminology, but general plan is clear / 8
Mostly clear, but needs some fine-tuning / 10
Totally clear
Justification of sampling design / 0
None given / 1 / 2
Weak justification / 3 / 4 / 5
Good justification
Development of frames / 0
No description / 1
Mentioned, but not enough detail / 2 / 3
Discussed, but not quite clear / 4 / 5
Clearly described
Point estimate / 0
I can’t figure out what you did or if it’s right. / 2
You did the wrong thing. / 4
You didn’t get it quite right; good effort / 6
I think you did the right thing; give more detail / 8
You did the right thing; but not clearly explained / 10
Correctly calculated; clearly described
Standard Error / 0
I can’t figure out what you did or if it’s right. / 2
You did the wrong thing. / 4
You didn’t get it quite right; good effort / 6
I think you did the right thing; give more detail / 8
You did the right thing; but not clearly explained / 10
Correctly calculated; clearly described
Summary of Pilot Study / 0
Not mentioned / 1 / 2
Not enough detail / 3 / 4
Too much detail / 5
Clear, concise summary
Statement of assumptions / 0
None stated and there are some. / 1
Stated some irrelevant assumptions or they are unclear / 2 / 3
Stated assumptions, but did not discuss the impact on your estimates / 4 / 5
Clearly stated assumptions; discussed how they may impact the estimate
Other relevant info / 0
I have many unanswered questions / 2
I have a couple of questions / 5
I have no unanswered questions.
Budget Report / 0
Not included / 3
Not clearly described / 5
Budget was well-accounted for
Well-written and well-organized / 0
Poorly organized, lots of grammar mistakes / 2 / 4
Well-organized, lots of grammar mistakes / 6 / 8 / 10
Few grammar mistakes, well-organized