Research Student Administration

UNIVERSITY OF BRADFORD

Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Examination Report form – further assessment of original or revised thesis

Form Guidance and Processes: Examiners must complete and sign a joint report on the form set out below. The completed form, both preliminary reports and thesis should be returned to the Postgraduate Research (PGR) Administrator within the Faculty/Academic Unit. The PGR Administrator should submit the form to Student Registry Services (Research) within two weeks of the oral or other examination.

Procedures for the conduct of research examinations are detailed within the ‘Guidance for Internal and External Examiners of Candidates for Research Degrees’ which is underpinned by the University’s Ordinances and Regulations for Research Degrees - available online at: (in Quick Links).

Examiners are expected to read the ‘Guidance for Internal and External Examiners of Candidates for Research Degrees’ and be familiar with the associated Ordinances and Regulations for Research Degrees before conducting the examination.

In addition, it is expected that examinations are conducted with regards to the University’s policies on Professional Conduct, Equality and Diversity - available online at:

Please note that, following approval by the Research Degrees Committee (RDC), a copy of this report will be forwarded to the Candidate.

Please ensure this form is typed (including Sections 3 & 4) and signed by all examiners.

Candidate
Full Name
UB Number
Title of Thesis
Faculty/Academic Unit
Date of Registration
Date and Place of Oral Examination [note: for re-assessment maybe N/A]
Supervisors
Independent Chair
Examiners
  1. Recommendation of Examiners (please check the appropriate box/es

Note 1 – In such circumstances it is necessary for Examiners to confirm in their report that the candidate has satisfied all requirements for the Degree of MPhil, as outlined in 12.1 in the ‘Guidance for Internal and External Examiners of Candidates for Research Degrees’.
1.1 / That the candidate be awarded the Degree of PhD /
1.2 / That the candidate be awarded the Degree of PhD subject to corrections being made to the thesis, including the abstract, to the satisfaction of the Internal Examiner (see Note 1 above).
Such minor corrections shall be completed within a period of three months of the examination. /
1.3 / That the candidate be awarded the Degree of MPhil (see Note 1 above /
1.4 / That no award be made and that the candidate be not permitted to revise and re-present the thesis. /
2. Assessment of the thesis (please check the appropriate box/es)
Yes No
(a) Is the literary presentation of the thesis satisfactory?

(b) Does the thesis contain original work of merit?

(c) Is the thesis worthy of publication either in full or in part?
(d) Does the candidate give evidence of:
(i) Competence in independent work?

(ii) Critical use of published work and source materials?
3. Report on the Candidate’s performance at the oral examination and on any additional written or practical examinations
Please check the appropriate box / es below to indicate whether the presence of Candidate’s supervisor / s at the oral examination (refer to the ‘Guidance for Internal and External Examiners for Candidates for Research Degrees’, Section 8)
The Candidate’s supervisors were not present

The Candidate’s Principal supervisor was present

The Candidate’s Associate Supervisor was present

Report on candidate’s performance at the oral or other examination

Continue on a separate page, as necessary. Any additional pages should be stapled to this form and should indicate clearly the Section(s) to which they refer:

4. Report on the thesis
Please give a joint critical appraisal of the thesis in approximately 500 words, including comments on:
  • the nature and scope of the investigation
  • the contribution made to the subject field, including the extent to which the thesis contains original, publishable work of merit
  • the quality of the submission and, where appropriate, of the investigative work described
  • when minor corrections the examiners should ensure that a list of corrections is released to the Candidate immediately after the examination and a copy is appended to this report
If as a result of examination the candidate is required to change either their title/subtitle/keywords of the thesis, please indicate this clearly in the report.
The preliminary reports on the thesis written by the individual examiners prior to examination do not constitute a joint exam report. However, the points raised on the individual preliminary reports can form the basis of the joint report below.
Please provide sufficient detail in order to prevent delay in the approval of the Candidate’s degree.
Report on the thesis
Continue on a separate page, as necessary. Any additional pages should be stapled to this form and should indicate clearly the Section(s) to which they refer.
Signature of Examiners
All Examiners and the Independent Chair (or Independent Mediator for staff candidate with two External Examiners) must sign the Examiners’ Report Form. Please print name and include the date in the table below, and sign after completing the Form.
Independent Chair / ______Date: ______
(dd/mm/yyyy)
Print name
External Examiner / ______Date: ______
(dd/mm/yyyy)
Print name
Internal Examiner / ______Date: ______
(dd/mm/yyyy)
Print Name

Once this has been signed by both Examiners and the Independent Chair, please return the signed form to the PGR Administrator in the candidate’s Faculty for the Director of PG Research to read and sign off. If the Director of PGR is the student’s supervisor or Internal Examiner, please pass to the Associate Dean of Research & Knowledge Transfer to read and sign off.

Director of PG Research in Candidate’s Faculty / ______Date: ______
(dd/mm/yyyy)
Print Name

As per Guidance, return to Student Registry Services(Research), University of Bradford, Richmond Building, Richmond Road, Bradford, BD7 1DP within two weeks of the oral or other examination.

This form is available online at: For queries about completing the Examiners’ Report Form and / or the research examination process please contact the Research Student Administration Team either by email on or by telephone on +44 (0)1274 2335408.

H:\AA\HUB\SAS\RESEARCH STUDENT ADMINISTRATION\STANDARD PRO FORMAS\PhD Form R and R November 2014.docx