Children’s Crusade
European history
Written by:Gary Dickson
Children’s Crusade,popular religious movement inEuropeduring the summer of 1212 in which thousands of young people took Crusading vows and set out to recoverJerusalemfrom theMuslims. Lasting only from May to September, the Children’s Crusade lacked official sanction and ended in failure; none of the participants reached the Holy Land. Nevertheless, the religious fervor it excited helped to initiate the Fifth Crusade (1218). It was arguably the first European youth movement.
Controversies
Although it is mentioned in more than 50chronicles(lists of historical events in chronological order) dating from the 13th century, much about the Children’s Crusade remains obscure. Reports in the chronicles often amount to no more than a line or two, and other sources are fragmentary and attimes unreliably embellished. As a result, crucial aspects of the Children’s Crusade remain controversial. For example, scholars of the period have debated whether the movement was really a Crusade and whether the participants were really young people.
Despite its popular designation, the Children’s Crusade was officially never aCrusade.Crusadescould come into existence only with papal approval, and PopeInnocent III(1198–1216) never summoned it. These self-proclaimed, unarmed Crusaders voiced their intention to regainJerusalemand recover the True Cross(a purported relic of the cross on whichJesuswascrucified)—which had been lost to the Muslims in theBattle of Ḥaṭṭīn(1187)—but said nothing about how they hoped to achieve their goals. Nevertheless, thepueri(Latin: “boys” or “children”)—the term used by 13th-century writers to describe participants in the movement—wore the insignia of thecross(as did all Crusaders) and took the Crusader’s vow, which was binding on those who were at least 14 years old. Moreover, the church recognized their vow as valid. This is known because in 1220 PopeHonorius IIIabsolved a “poor student” named Otto from his Crusading vow. Although Honorius does refer to “a multitude of otherpueri” who joined the movement, only Otto’s papal absolution is recorded. Although a majority of the chronicles that mention the Children’s Crusade do so in disapproving terms, all of them refer to it as a Crusade.
Were thepuerireally young people? Some scholars, such as the German historian Peter Raedts, have argued that “pueri” in the chronicles and other documents does not signify an age group but instead describes a social class of impoverished landless peasants and day labourers of indeterminate age. In fact, many of thepueriandpuelle(“girls”) would indeed have belonged to such a social class. Yet, this by no means rules out their youthfulness. The chroniclers emphasized the prevalence of young people in relation to other groups within the Children’s Crusade, including urban laborers, mothers, and the elderly. In addition, several chroniclers noted that some parents imprisoned their children in their homes to prevent them from joining. Thus, it seems likely that young people were the most conspicuous element within the Children’s Crusade as well as its leaders, though it is also probable that the movement was not composed exclusively of young people.
Origins
Popular movements of religious revivalism like the Children’s Crusade usually appeared when official Crusades were preached. Preaching aroused collective enthusiasm, particularly in areas with a long tradition of Crusading, as in the town ofChartresand its surrounding region (the Chartrain) in north-centralFrance. Beginning at the time of the First Crusade in the late 11th century and continuing into the 13th century, successive waves of Crusading fervor swept over this region. During the winter of 1211 and the spring of 1212 theAlbigensianCrusade was preached against the hereticalCatharsof southern France, resulting in strong military recruitment from the Chartrain. Spain, on Christendom’s western frontier, was the scene of another Crusading crisis. A Muslim invasion from North Africa in 1210 led to the fall of the castle of Salvatierra in 1211. A climactic battle was expected byPentecostin 1212. Pope Innocent III anxiously attempted to mobilize the prayers of Christians on behalf of the threatened Spanish church by holding processions in Rome on May 16, 1212.
It is likely that similar processions were held at Chartres on May 20. In all probability, a shepherd boy,Stephen of Cloyes, and some of his fellow workers took part in them. The enthusiasm generated by these processions gave birth to a popular Crusading movement whose aims were summed up in acclamations shouted out by thepueri: “Lord God, raise up Christendom!” and “Lord God, return to us the True Cross!”
The Crusade
Under Stephen’s leadership, the French participants in the Children’s Crusade assembled atSaint-Denis, probably during an annual fair known as the Lendit fair (June 8–24). Contemporary estimates of the size of Stephen’s following ranged from 15,000 to nearly 30,000. The anonymous chronicler ofLaonsays that Stephen was instructed by a poor pilgrim—who was actually Jesus—to deliver letters to KingPhilip IIof France. Nothing is revealed about the contents of these letters, if indeed they existed, nor of any meeting with the king. The king, however, ordered thepuerito disperse. Although nothing further is known of Stephen, bands of Frenchpuerimay have then headed north and east to the town ofSaint-Quentin. At this point the Frenchpueridisappear from the historical record, their whereabouts uncertain, but it is possible that some of them arrived in the German city ofCologneabout July 14–18. Contact with the Frenchpueriis the most likely origin of the Children’s Crusade inGermany, which began about that time.
Attempting to reach the Holy Land,Nicholas of Cologneled the Germanpuerisouthward toMainzandSpeyer. There is reason to suppose that there were Frenchpueri, as well aspuerifrom the region between France and Germany, among them. Little is known about Nicholas except that he originated from the countryside near Cologne and carried a cross shaped like a T (the tau cross), which was his charismatic emblem. Invoking the biblicalExodusfrom Egypt and the parting of theRed Sea, they proclaimed that theMediterranean Seawould part for them, a motif of divine election that implies some degree of identification with theIsraelites. Nicholas then led thepueriacross theAlpsto the Italian cities ofPiacenzaandGenoa, where, however, they failed to find a ship to take them to the Holy Land. Their ultimate fate remains uncertain; some of them might have traveled by ship toMarseille, while others apparently journeyed toRometo ask papal officials to nullify or defer their Crusade vows. Of the more than 7,000pueriwho arrived inGenoa, many remained—cheap labor was needed there and in other thriving Italian cities. Thus, what began as a popular Crusade probably ended as a massive labor migration.
According to the chronicles, the Children’s Crusade was an utter disaster. Few of the Crusaders returned from their journey; most died of hunger or thirst or were drowned at sea, while others were sold as slaves. The chroniclers’ story carried a clear message: God did not will it. Be this as it may, the Children’s Crusade did confirm Innocent III’s belief that Crusading enthusiasm was far from dead. Less than one year later he summoned the Fifth Crusade.
Despite the extreme brevity of the movement, interest in the Children’s Crusade continued through the centuries. It has been depicted in works by authors as diverse asVoltaire,Bertolt Brecht,Agatha Christie, andKurt Vonnegut, and countless children’s books have been written about it. Its evocative themes still delight the literary imagination.