CASE NO. 2005G-001
COMPLAINANT: DEANNA L. HILL
33114 EAGLES GLEN CT.
N. RIDGEVILLE, OH 44039
HM: (440) 748-1375
CELL: (440) 610-6221
RESPONDENT: REP. EARL MARTIN COUNSEL: Donald C. Brey
32290 LAKE RD. Chester, Willcox & Saxbe
AVON LAKE, OH 44012 65 E. State St., Ste. 1000
HM: (440) 933-3213 Columbus, OH 43215
WK: (614) 644-9076
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.10(FAILURE TO FILE COMPLETE AND ACCURATE REPORTS)
3517.13(CONCEALMENT)
OFFICE: HOUSE REPRESENTATIVE - 57TH DISTRICT
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 2, 2004
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 6/8/06THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE REQUEST TO WITHDRAW
THE COMPLAINT FILED BY THE COMPLAINANT.
CASE NO. 2005G-002
COMPLAINANT: JASON ASLINGER
3615 U.S. 127 SOUTH
GREENVILLE, OH 45331
(937) 548-9227
RESPONDENT: JASON ASLINGER
3615 U.S. 127 SOUTH
GREENVILLE, OH 45331
(937) 548-9227
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.10(D)(1)(LATE FILING OF A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)
OFFICE: DARKE COUNTY MUNICIPAL COURT JUDGE
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 2/24/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.10(D)(1), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE NOR REFER
THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
CASE NO. 2005E-003
COMPLAINANT: JOHN G. AUGUSTINE
17670 FARMINGTON RD.
W. FARMINGTON, OHIO 44491
(440) 548-2414
RESPONDENT: PARKMAN CITIZENS FOR REASONABLE ZONING
DEBRA WILSON
16775 MADISON RD.
MIDDLEFIELD, OH 44062
(440) 548-8113
FAX: (440) 834-1440
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.22(FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: ISSUE 29 - ZONING
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 2, 2004
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 2/24/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE AND DISMISSED THE MATTER.
CASE NO. 2005E-004
PAGE 1 OF 2
CURTIS V. CITIZENS FOR FAIR TAXATION, ET AL.
COMPLAINANT: LYNN MOON CURTIS
1676 EAST 337TH ST.
EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095
(440) 350-2168
(440) 946-7729
RESPONDENT: CITIZENS FOR FAIR TAXATION
ANDREW WOOD, TREASURER
36343 VALLEY VISTA DRIVE
EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095
(440) 953-3884
THOMAS L. KOONS
36230 VALLEY VISTA DRIVE
EASTLAKE, OH 44095
(440) 946-3025
WILLIAM J. TSCHANTZ
36231 VALLEY VISTA DRIVE
EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095
(440) 951-2554
PATRICK J. BOYCE
36555 GARRETTS COVE
EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095
(440) 918-1685
MARK R. REDDICK
1315 EAST 354TH STREET
EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.22(B)(FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: EASTLAKE CITY COUNCIL - WARD 1
ELECTION: DECEMBER 14, 2004
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 6/30/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)(2) AS TO THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT:
1.) "SHE WAS A LOYAL CRONY TO FORMER MAYOR, DAN DILIBERTO."
CASE NO. 2005E-004
PAGE 1 OF 2
CURTIS V. CITIZENS FOR FAIR TAXATION, ET AL.
THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)(2) BY THE OHIO REVISED CODE'S STANDARD OF CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:
2.) "SHE WAS DERELICT IN HER DUTIES AS CHAIRWOMAN OF THE FINANCE COMMITTEE."
THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)(2) AS TO THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS:
3.) "SHE FAILED TO WATCH OVERSPENDING AND VOTED YEAR AFTER YEAR TO APPROVE THE BUDGET EVEN THOUGH IT WAS EVIDENT THE CITY WAS HEADED FOR FISCAL DISASTER."
4.) "SHE CHOSE TO IGNORE THE FOREWARNINGSAND VOTED TO APPROVE THE BASEBALL STADIUM PROJECT AND EVERY EXPENDITURE RELATING TO IT."
5.) "SHE SUPPORTED YOUR INCOME TAX CREDIT REDUCTION WHICH RESULTED IN AN INCREASE IN YOUR TAXES."
AS PENALTY FOR THE VIOLATION THE COMMISSION FOUND GOOD CAUSE NOT TO REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION, BUT INSTEAD TO ISSUE A LETTER OF PUBLIC REPRIMAND AGAINST THE CITIZENS FOR FAIR TAXATION. THE COMMISSION ALSO FOUND GOOD CAUSE SHOWN NOT TO REFER THE RESPONDENTS, THOMAS L. KOONS, WILLIAM J. TSCHANTZ, PATRICK J. BOYCE AND MARK R. REDDICK TO THE LAKE CO. PROSECUTOR FOR FUTHER CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AND NOT TO ISSUE A LETTER OF PUBLIC REPRIMAND.
CASE NO. 2005E-005
COMPLAINANT: WILLIAM B. MORAND COUNSEL: THEODORE J. FRONCEK
3363 ST. GEORGES WAY 1208 SYCAMORE ST.
LOVELAND, OHIO 45140 CINCINNATI, OH 45202
(513) 241-5670
RESPONDENT: LEE SPEIDEL COUNSEL: CHRISTOPHER P. FINNEY
7205 KINGS MILLS ROAD FINNEY, STAGNARO, SABA
MAINEVILLE, OH 45039 & KLUSMEIER CO. LPA
2623 ERIE AVE.
CINCINNATI, OH 45208
(513) 533-2980
FAX: (513) 533-2990
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.21(B)(10)(FALSE STATEAMENT)
OFFICE: DEERFIELD TWP. TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 4, 2003
PRIORS: 2003E-064
DISPOSITION: 5/12/05 THE COMMISSION DECLARED AN ADMINISTRATIVE DISMISSAL.
CASE NO. 2005G-006
COMPLAINANT: DAVID PALMER
4012 ALAMO COURT
ELDORADO HILLS, CA 95762
(916) 984-7004
RESPONDENT: THOMAS MOYER COUNSEL: Donald C. Brey
CHIEF JUSTICE OH SP. CT. Chester, Willcox & Saxbe
65 S FRONT ST 65 E. State St., Ste. 1000
COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 387-9000
ALICE ROBIE RESNICK COUNSEL: DONALD BREY
JUSTICE OH SP. CT.
65 S FRONT ST
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
(614) 387-9000
TERRENCE O’DONNELL COUNSEL: Christopher N. Slagle
JUSTICE OH SP. CT. Brickler & Eckler, LLP
65 S FRONT ST 100 S. Third St.
COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 387-9000 227-8826
FAX: 227-2390
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.092(B)(C)(4)(SOLICITING AND/OR ACCEPTING CONTRIBUTIONS
OF STATE EMPLOYEES)
3517.13(G)(1)(CONCEALMENT)
3517.13(O)(USING CAMPAIGN FUNDS FOR PERSONAL USE)
OFFICE: OHIO SUPREME COURT
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 4/28/05 THE PORTION OF THE COMPLAINT ALLEGING A VIOLATION BY JUSTICE ALICE ROBIE RESNICK WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.
IN THE PORTION OF THE COMPLAINT ALLEGING A VIOLATION BY JUSTICE TERRENCE O’DONNELL, THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION.
5/26/05 IN THE PORTION OF THE COMPLAINT ALLEGING A VIOLATION BY CHIEF JUSTICE THOMAS MOYER, THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION.
THE COMMISSION DENIED THE REQUESTS OF THE RESPONDENTS CHIEF JUSTICE MOYER AND JUSTICE O’DONNELL TO FIND THE COMPLAINT
FRIVOLOUS.
CASE NO. 2005D-007
COMPLAINANT: EDWARD KLIMAS
4893 SEDGEWICK RD
LYNDHURST, OH 44124
(216) 319-5100
RESPONDENT: ENOM, INC. ATTN: LEGAL
2002 156TH AVE NE SUITE 300
UNIGARD PARK, MCKINLEY BUILDING
BELLEVUE, WA 98007
(425) 274-4500
LANCE CROSBY, ESQ.
CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
THE PLANET.COM
1333 STEMMONS FREEWAY
SUITE 110
DALLAS, TX 75207
(214) 782-7800
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.20(NO DISCLAIMER)
ISSUE: OHIO LOCAL SCHOOL LEVY
ELECTION: MAY 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 4/28/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20.
CASE NO. 2005E-008
COMPLAINANT: KEVIN J. ZEIHER
925 CEDAR POINT CHAUSSEE
SANDUSKY, OH 44870
(419) 627-0414
RESPONDENT: CITIZENS FOR PROTECTION COUNSEL: RICK BRUNNER
OF PROPERTY (CPPR) BRUNNER LAW FIRM
P. O. BOX 335 545 E TOWN ST
MILAN, OH 44846 COLS., OH 43215
241-5550
241-5551 (FAX)
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.10(FAILURE TO FILE TO FILE COMPLETE AND ACCURATE REPORTS)
3517.01(b)(5) (FAILURE TO LIST THE AMOUNTS OF CONTRIBUTIONS FROM ITS MEMBERS)
3517.01(B)(6) OR 3517.08(G) (FAILURE TO ACCOUNT FOR EXPENDITURES FROM OR FUNDS RAISED AT FUNDRAISERS)
3517.21(B)(10)(FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: ERIE COUNTY COMMON PLEAS COURT JUDGE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 2004
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION:
CASE NO. 2005G-009
COMPLAINANT: PATRICK J. O’MALLEY COUNSEL: KENNETH J. FISHER CO
500 SOLON ROAD 2100 TERMINAL TOWER
CHAGRIN FALLS, OHIO 44022 50 PUBLIC SQ
(440) 247-0690 CLEVELAND, OH 44113
(216) 696-7661
FAX: (216) 696-0439
RESPONDENT: TIMOTHY J. O’MALLEY COUNSEL: DONALD J. MCTIGUE
20606 PEMBROOKE OVAL 3886 N. HIGH ST
STRONGSVILLE, OH 44136 COLUMBUS, OH 43215
(216) 780-7427 263-7000
263-7078
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.20(A)(2)(NO DISCLAIMER)
3517.13(G)(1) & 3517.13(B) (MISREPRESENT CONTRIBUTIONS AND FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE REPORT)
3599.03(A)(CORPORATE CONTRIBUTIONS)
3517.10(A) & 3517.13(B)(FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND
ACCURATE REPORT)
OFFICE: CUYAHOGA COUNTY RECORDER
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 2004
PRIORS: 98R-431 98R-664 2004E-050
DISPOSITION: 8/24/06 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED FROM THE COMPLAINANT, PATRICK J. O’MALLEY, THE NOTICE OF DISMISSAL.
CASE NO. 2005E-010
COMPLAINANT: GARY D. BONNELL
616 BROADVIEW CIRCLE
EAST LIVERPOOL, OH 43920
(330) 385-3440
CELL: (330) 383-3440
RESPONDENT: THE EAST LIVERPOOL BOARD OF EDUCATION
STEPHEN BEADNELL, PRESIDENT
BRIAN FARNSWORTH, VICE-PRESIDENT
MAUREEN ARONOFF
DENISE TAYLOR
LARRY LONG, JR.
DOUGLAS T. HISCOX, SUPERINTENDENT
500 MARYLAND AVENUE
EAST LIVERPOOL, OH 43920
(330) 385-7132
CITIZENS FOR BETTER SCHOOLS COUNSEL: James Thomas
DAN DIETZ, TREASURER Squires, Sanders & Dempsey
318 THOMPSON AVE. 4900 Key Tower
EAST LIVERPOOL, OH 43920 127 Public Square
(330) 386-9515 Cleveland, OH 44114
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.22(B)(2)(FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: SCHOOL LEVY RENAL
ELECTION: MAY 3, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 5/2/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)(2) BY THE RESPONDENT CITIZENS FOR BETTER SCHOOLS, DAN DIETZ, TREASURER, BY THE OHIO REVISED CODE’S STANDARD OF CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE. THE COMMISSION FOUND THAT THERE WAS GOOD CAUSE PRESENT NOT TO REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
CASE NO. 2005E-011
COMPLAINANT: JAMES W. WALKER
1326 MAIN AVE., W
MASSILLON, OH 44647
(330) 834-0551
RESPONDENT: BARBARA L. LIGHTFOOT
1523 WALNUT RD., SW
MASSILLON, OH 44647
(330) 832-7020
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.21(B)(9) AND (10)(FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: MASSILLON CITY COUNCILMAN WARD 5
ELECTION: MAY 3, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 4/28/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE.
CASE NO. 2005E-012
COMPLAINANT: COLUMBUS BAR OWNERS POLITICAL COUNCIL: Phillip L. Harmon
ACTION COMMITTEE, A.K.A. BARPAC 6649 N. High St.
C/O DIMCHE KUZMANOVSKI, TREASURER Suite 105
2151 E. DUBLIN-GRANVILLE RD., #213 Worthington, Oh 43085
COLUMBUS, OH 43229 (614) 433-9502
Fax (614) 433-9503
RESPONDENT: AMERICAN LUNG ASSOCIATION OF OHIO
C/O LINUS RYLAND, TREASURER
1950 ARLINGATE LANE
COLUMBUS, OH 43228
CITIZENS FOR SMOKE FREE COLUMBUS
C/O DONALD J. MCTIGUE, TREASURER
3888 N. HIGH ST.
COLUMBUS, OH 43214
(614) 263-7000
(FAX) (614) 263-7078
ALLEGATIONS: R.C. §3517.10(A)(1)(FAILURE TO FILE CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS TIMELY)
R.C. §3517.10(D)(1) AND R.C. §3517.10(A)(FAILURE TO REGISTER AS PAC, NO FINANCE REPORTS)
R.C. §3517.22(B) AND R.C. §3517.22(B)(2)(FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: INNIATIVE PETITION
ELECTION: MAY 3, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 4/28/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)(2) ALL REMAINING ALLEGATIONS WERE SET FOR HEARING.
CASE NO. 2005D-013
COMPLAINANT: JOHN PETERS
P. O. BOX 808
JACKSON, OH 45640
(740) 286-2708
RESPONDENT: EDDIE HUGHES
202 COLUMBIA ST.
JACKSON, OH 45640
(740) 286-3142
ALLEGATIONS: R.C. §3517.20(NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: JACKSON CITY COUNCILMAN AT LARGE
ELECTION: MAY 3, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 6/9/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20.
CASE NO. 2005E-014
COMPLAINANT: MICHAEL C. PALERMO, JR.
1518 WHITE ASH DRIVE
PAINESVILLE TWP., OH 44077
(440) 639-7185
FAX: (440) 995-6857
RESPONDENT: C.A.R.E. COMMITTEE
DR. FRED LISY, TREASURER
13596 LEROY CENTER ROAD
PAINESVILLE, OH 44077
ALLEGATIONS: R.C. §3517.21 AND R.C. §3517.22(FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: PAINESVILLE TWP. SCHOOL BOND ISSUE - ISSUE 4
ELECTION: MAY 3, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 5/12/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE AND DISMISSED THE MATTER.
CASE NO. 2005E-015
COMPLAINANT: BRIAN K. MURPHY
1533 LAKE SHORE DR.
COLUMBUS, OH 43204
(614) 488-0400
FAX: (614) 488-0401
RESPONDENT: BOB MCEWEN COUNSEL: CHARLES SAXBE
MCEWEN FOR CONGRESS CHESTER, WILLCOX &
P.O. BOX 115 SAXBE
BATAVIA, OH 45103 65 E STATE ST.
(513)474-8683 SUITE 1000
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
(513) 600-3588 (CPGN MGR - WES FARNO)
FAX: (513) 474-4479
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.21(B)(1)(FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: U.S. HOUSE OF RESPRESENTATIVES 2ND CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT
ELECTION: JUNE 14, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 6/14/05 THE COMISSION ACCEPTED A REQUEST FROM THE
COMPLAINANT TOWITHDRAW THE COMPLAINT.
CASE NO. 2005E-016
COMPLAINANT: BERKSHIRE BOARD OF EDUCATION
GEAUGA COUNTY, OHIO
LEE IMHOFF, PRESIDENT
14259 CLARIDON-TROY ROAD
P. O. BOX 364
BURTON, OH 44021
RESPONDENT: JAMES DURALIA
18309 MUMFORD ROAD
BURTON, OH 44021
SCOTT WEBER
C/O THE GUNRUNNER
14548 MAIN ST.
P. O. BOX 803
BURTON, OH 44021
PERSON OR PERSONS UNKNOWN
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.22(B)(2)(FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: SCHOOL LEVY ISSUE
ELECTION: FEBRUARY 8, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 6/30/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE AND
DISMISSED THE MATTER.
CASE NO. 2005E-017
COMPLAINANT: JUDITH A. BOULTON
962 N. STATE ST.
PAINESVILLE, OH 44077-4221
(440) 358-0744
RESPONDENT: PAINESVILLE CITIZENS FOR COUNSEL: JOSEPH M. GURLEY
SAFETY COMMITTEE LAW DIRECTOR CITY OF PAINESVLE
DAVID KOMJATI, TREASURER 240 E. MAIN ST.
565 MAGNOLIA DR. PAINESVILLE, OH 44077
PAINESVILLE, OH 44077 (440) 354-3800
(440) 352-2673 (440) 357-5511 (FAX)
CITY OF PAINESVILLE COUNSEL: DONALD J. MCTIGUE
7 RICHMOND STREET 3886 N HIGH ST
P. O. BOX 601 COLUMBUS, OH 43214
PAINESVILLE, OH 44077-0601 263-7000
(440) 352-9301
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.22(UNFAIR ACTIVITIES IN ISSUE CAMPAIGN)
OFFICE: BALLOT ISSUE
ELECTION: AUGUST 2, 2005
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 7/28/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22.
CASE NO. 2005G-018
COMPLAINANT: VICTOR V. VIGLUICCI
466 S. CHESTNUT ST.
RAVENNA, OH 44266
(330) 297-3850
(330) 297-3856
FAX: (330) 297-4594
RESPONDENT: LOUISE A. O’BRIEN
1849 EDGEWOOD ST. NE
WARREN, OH 44483
(330) 372-4363
MICHAEL J. O’BRIEN COUNSEL: DONALD J. MCTIGUE
1849 EDGEWOOD ST., NE 3886 N HIGH ST
WARREN, OH 44483 COLUMBUS, OH 43214
(330) 372-4363 263-7000
AND
MICHAEL J. O’BRIEN
CITY HALL
391 MAHONING, NW
WARREN, OH 44483
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.10(D)(3)(a) (REQUIRES A CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE TO ESTABLISH AN ACCOUNT THAT IS SEPARATE FROM A PERSONAL OR BUSINESS ACCOUNT OF THE CANDIDATE OR OF A MEMBER OF THE CANDIDATE’S CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE.)
3517.13(O) (NO BENEFICIARY OF A CAMPAIGN FUND OR OTHER PERSON SHALL CONVERT FOR PERSONAL USE …. ANYTHING OF VALUE FROM THE BENEFICIARY’S CAMPAIGN FUND.)
3517.10(B)(4) (FAILED TO PROVIDE THE REQUIRED INFORMATION ON THE STATEMENT OF CONTRIBUTIONS RECEIVED.)
OFFICE: TRUMBULL COUNTY COMMISSIONER
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 9/1/05 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.10(D)(3)(a), R.C. §3517.13(O) AND R.C. §3517.10(B)(4) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $1,875.00.
9/29/05 RECEIVED FROM LOUISE A. AND MICHAEL F. O’BRIEN CHECK #4554 IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,875.00.
CASE CLOSED
CASE NO. CASE NO. 2005G-019
COMPLAINANT: VICTOR VIGLUICCI
466 S. CHESTNUT ST.
RAVENNA, OH 44266
(330) 297-3850
(330) 297-3856
FAX: (330) 297-4594
RESPONDENT: JOSEPH J. ANGELO JR. COUNSEL: DONALD J. MCTIGUE
2163 MARY DRIVE 3886 N HIGH ST
WARREN, OH 44483 COLUMBUS, OH 43214
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.10(D)(3)(a) (REQUIRES A CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE TO ESTABLISH AN ACCOUNT THAT IS SEPARATE FROM A PERSONAL OR BUSINESS ACCOUNT OF THE CANDIDATE OR OF A MEMBER OF THE CANDIDATE’S CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE.
3517.10(A) (A CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE MUST FILE A FULL, TRUE AND ITEMIZED STATEMENT)
3517.13(B), (C) & (D) (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE STATEMENT)
3517.13(O) (NO BENEFICIARY OF A CAMPAIGN FUND OR OTHER PERSON SHALL CONVERT FOR PERSONAL USE …. ANYTHING OF VALUE FROM THE BENEFICIARY’S CAMPAIGN FUND.)
OFFICE: TRUMBULL COUNTY COMMISSIONER
ELECTION:
PRIORS: 2003R-526 91R-34 91R-496
DISPOSITION: 11/3/05 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE MATTER AS THE ALLEGATIONS IN THE COMPLAINT WERE BEYOND THE 2-YEAR STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.
CASE NO. 2005G-020
COMPLAINANT: JOSEPH E. LACEY
161 HUFFMAN AVE
DAYTON, OH 45403-1915
RESPONDENT: E. DONIECE GATLIFF COUNSEL: DONALD BREY
1737 RAVENWOOD AVE. 65 E. STATE ST
DAYTON, OH 45406 SUITE 1000
(937) 278-0254 COLS., OH 43215
YVONNE ISAACS
4812 NORTHGATE CT.
DAYTON, OH 45416
GAIL H. LITTLEJOHN
1253 HOOK ESTATE DR
DAYTON, OH 45405
(937) 463-4932
TRACY L. RUSCH
1213 BROADVIEW BLVD
DAYTON, OH 45419
(937) 296-9781
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.10(FAILED TO FILE A FULL AND TRUE ITEMIZED STATEMENT)
3517.081(TWO OR MORE CANDIDATES IN ONE COMMITTEE)