- 1 -

2011 / 2012 – ANNEXURE B

127 Judgments / Court Orders

(Only 127 Judgments / Court Orders were received from 1099 Litigation, all other matters are either pending, struck off the roll, legal opinions or letters of demand)

SUBJECT / NATURE OF LITIGATION / JUDGMENT / COURT ORDER
  1. Cawood Nicholas (2011/13630)
/ Civic Services / Orderto release the Plaintiff`s passport
  1. Abdi Liban Barre / Minister of Home Affairs (21342/11)
/ Refugee Affairs / Orderto issue applicant with a passport
  1. Mohammed Shabbir Khan / Minister of Home Affairs (1083/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Application for temporary residence permit dismissed with cost(de bonis propriis)
  1. Abdul Rasheed / Minister of Home Affairs (1032/11)
/ Immigration / Application for temporary residence permit dismissed with cost(de bonis propriis)
  1. Masilela Sophie Ndlelehle / Minister of Home Affairs (21289/11)
/ Civic Services / Applicant’s application to amend her date of birth dismissed with costs
  1. Chico Maduako Ayozie / Minister of Home Affairs (24494/11)
/ Refugee Affairs Urgent Application / Application to order Department to return confiscated passport and Identity Document, dismissed with costs
  1. Edward Mankango / Minister of Home Affairs (24621/11)
/ Refugee Identity Document / Refugee Identity Document issued to applicant by agreement
  1. Portia Frans / Director-General of Home Affairs (4856)
/ Identity Document / Applicant’s applicationfor Identity Documentwas dismissed with costs, Applicant was in possession of fraudulent documents
  1. Mahlogonolo Eunice Teffu (27770/11)
/ Customary Marriage / Department abided by the Court Order (customary marriage -- unopposed)
  1. Muhammad Khalid, Amtul Hafeez and Muhammad Hamza / Minister ofHome Affairs
/ Refugee Affairs / Orderto consider and finalise temporary residence permit
  1. Eisenberg & Associates, Yung –Lin Yen, Fokelina Wiljagaarden Immigration Services t\a Visa One / Minister of Home Affairs (10043/11)
/ Immigration / Order to consider and finalise temporary residence permit
  1. Lin Shuqin / Minister of Home Affairs (11/18433)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Lin Qinqxia / Minister of Home Affairs (869/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant and return his passport
  1. Henriques Braganca, Michelle Pereira / Minister of Home Affairs (17701/11)
/ Immigration / Applicant for an exemption in terms of Section 31(2)(b) of the Immigration Act, dismissed with costs
  1. Ibrahim Abdullahi Anshur / Minister of Home Affairs; DG; United nations high commissioner for refugees (31186/11)
/ Immigration / Order to issue applicant with a Refugee Identity Document
  1. Dino Dissalen / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Applicant’s application to stayhis deportation dismissed with costs
  1. Tshibangu Tshitamba / Minister of Home Affairs (30122/11)
/ Immigration / Order to consider and decide applicant’s application for permanent residenceapplication
  1. Jackson Mtegekurora / Minister of Home Affairs (21599/2011)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to stay Applicant’s deportation
  1. Dieudonne Karahirimba / Minister of Home Affairs (22277/2011)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Karibul Alam / Minister of Home Affairs (22839/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Application for Temporary Residence Permit dismissed with costs
  1. Yetneberk Weldemeskel & 19 others / Minister of Home Affairs (24012/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Sibomana Hilali Hamisi / Minister of Home Affairs (2011/24237)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Desale Deboch Atiso / Minister of Home Affairs (1956/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Yene Woldemeskel Bula & 18 others / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 others (28693/2011)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Asif Rasool Bhat / Minister of Home Affairs (8783/2011)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to return applicant’s permit
  1. Fonyam Ngum (Nguh) / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (14499/11)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Refiloe Boledi Lekolwane / Minister of Home Affairs (42736/11)
/ Customary Marriage / Department abided by the Court Order (customary marriage - unopposed)
  1. Anwar Hossain / Minister of Home Affairs and Director-General 2561/11
/ Immigration / Order to consider and finalise business permit
  1. Sadam Kize / Minister of Home Affairs (31875/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Tanveer Hussain / Minister of Home Affairs (31974/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Ali Asad Ullah; Tanya Ulla A (previously Smiltneek) / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General and Immigration of Klerksdorp HA 48181/11
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to consider and finalise permanent residence Permit
  1. Kadire Ibiro Ersumo / Minister of Home Affairs (2599/11)
/ Refugee Affairs Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Sumaiyah Suleman Sadar, Idrish Gulam Mohmed / Minister of Home Affairs (11/33575)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Zhuang Jin Ming / Minister of Home Affairs (33804/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Applicant’s application for unlawful detention dismissed with costs
  1. Maditaba Angelina Nathane / Minister of Home Affairs (28022/11)
/ Marriage / Department abided by the Court Order (customary marriage -- unopposed)
  1. Zheng Tong Chen, Rong Huang, Yu Hua Chen, Wei Min Ni, Xiang Lin Zheng, Ming Chen, Mei Mei Chen, Guo Ying Zhang / Minister of Police, Station Commander: Bethal; Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General of Home Affairs; Provincial Manager: Mpumalanga (57376/11)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
  1. Abrar Muhammad / Minister of Home Affairs; Nokwanda Eunice Nkalashe; the station commander, SAPS King Williams town 1710/11
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Prince Mangosuthu Gatsha Buthelezi, MP and Mosiuoa Lekota, MP / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (Delai Lama matter)
/ Immigration / Order declaring delay in considering and deciding applicant’s application fora permit unlawful
  1. Tshebeletso Gandy Kgutlo / Minister of Home Affairs 46725/11
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela pending judicial review
  1. Musena Nicole Dekoba / Director-General and Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela pending judicial review
  1. Qaisr Mehmood / Minister of Home Affairs 47312/11
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela pending judicial review
  1. Yolanda Ali (born) Magoga 568/11 / Minister of Home Affairs 4359/11
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Lakhiswa Alicia Iqbal (born) Lolwana 567/11 / Minister of Home Affairs 4358/11
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Vuyokazi Iqbal (born) Nonjiwu 566/11 / Minister of Home Affairs 4357/11
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Mohamond Sumon / Minister of Home Affairs & Director-General (3987/2011)
/ Refugee Affairs / Orderto consider and finalisepermanentresidence permit
  1. Detention of Angolan for over 180 days: Pendro Miguel
/ Refugee / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Orashid Harun MD / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Yves Okenge Musafiri 354/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Mohamed Aman Miah and Elizabeth Joan Davie / Minister of Home Affairs 23474/11
/ Immigration / Applicant’s refusal of entry into Republic upheld by Court
  1. Shamim, Mohammed 00133/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Ebenezer Agyet 00155/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Maru Weda 0015712 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Islam Taraqul, Farouque Mohammed, Shahin Mohammed, Jinnah Mohammed 01897/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Dareje Tefera Ossamo / Head of Lindela repatriation centre; head of Pretoria asylum determination centre; minister of home affairs; director-general of home affairs (3352/12) +
  2. 9914/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Hundabo Adimsu Yohans 01869/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Alamu Lambino 01871/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Refugee Affairs / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Salle Menoha Abaet 01408/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Refugee Affairs / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Samuel Girma Debelo and 11 Others / Minister of Home Affairs 02079/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Luzolo Vuvu / Minister of Home Affairs 01832/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Sokhawat Hossan/ Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Nganga Rikem Marie Louisa 02251/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Hussain Munawar 02252/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Kelemwork Tefera 02249/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Daisy Debra Chikura 4711/12 / Minister of Home Affairs
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Aasif Iqbalbhai Diwan / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 Others 6529/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for Temporary Residence Permit
  1. Anvar Abdulhamid Master / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 Others 6359/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for Temporary Residence Permit
  1. Phillipe Mwaku Kabuika / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 Others 6517/12
/ Refugee Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela pending judicial review
  1. Jaspal Singh 6528/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Efrem Wondimu Dady / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 Others 04199/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Bundaye Tarefa Chafamo; Simon Yohannes Kito / Minister of Home Affairs; Chairperson: Refugee Appeal Board; Refugee Reception Office 1423/12
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Asato Akililo; Solomon Solfam; Dejane Yekob / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General of Home Affairs; Bosasa (pty) ltd 05017/12
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Solomon Wolde Abuse / Minister of Home Affairs (12/05959)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Desalegne Gadebo Degaga/ Minister of Home Affairs (12/005960)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Rachid Lamaime / Minister of Home Affairs (12/05958)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Hasees UR Rahman (NASIR Iqbal) / Minister of Home Affairs (12/06361)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Amjad Muhammad / Minister of Home Affairs (12/06156)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Rubel Halder / Minister of Home Affairs (06359/12)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Ketcha Mbitong / Minister of Home Affairs (12/06155)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Rubel Haladar / Minister of Home Affairs (06359/12)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Chakebo Adore / Minister of Home Affairs (12/05952)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Frank Donatien Mukendi / Minister of Home Affairs (12/06169)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Suleto Mishamo and Bagigo Deseleni / Minister oh Home Affairs (12/05954)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Abara Wolda / Minister of Home Affairs (12/06360)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Tshilombo Kazadi / Minister of Home Affairs (12/06888)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Wosema Wondemu / Minister of Home Affairs (07314/12)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Bahati Banwesize / Minister of Home Affairs (12/07577)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Abos Mathiwes / Minister of Home Affairs (07313/12)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Semamo Tamrat (1587/12)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Hawel Ibrahim/ Minister of Home Affairs (1586/12)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Dawud Abdulaziz Ali / Minister of Home Affairs (12/7982)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Tshibangu Tshitunda / Minister of Home Affairs (12/08060)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. YohansDeleleni / Minister of Home Affairs (12/07973)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela pending judicial review
  1. Diana Gorgos & 4 others / Minister of Home Affairs &3 others (4244/12)
/ Immigration / Court ruled in Department’s favour. Applications for work permits denied due to the withdrawal of corporate work permit of Mavericks Revue Bar cc
  1. Alemo Helsebo & 7 others / Minister of Home Affairs (12/07983)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Steven Ntamb Murumb / Minister of Home Affairs (12/08379)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Idowu Lateef Sikuola / Minister of Home Affairs (08174/2012)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Mohamed Turay / Minister of Home Affairs (12/09043)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Tsikala Emmanuel / Minister of Home Affairs (12/09046)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. HsuHsein- Wen / Minister of Home Affairs (12/08923)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Dongmo Tsafack Rollin / Minister of Home Affairs (12/09044)
/ Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Mohammed Abdeifat Abdelkarm / Minister of Home Affairs (12/09800)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Lulwa Dieudonne Findi / Ministerof Home Affairs (12/9899)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Mbumba Gracia / Minister of home Affairs (12/9986)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
  1. Anamo Yhannis Lamebo / Minister of Home Affairs (12/f)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Tafero Lanegano Lambebo / Minister of Home Affairs (12/09992)
/ Refugee Affairs / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Leo Nzita Joao / Minister of Home Affairs (12/9988)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Kibezi Kulo Alfredy / Minister of Home Affairs (12/09989)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Kalore Rajato / Minister of Home Affairs 10683/12
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Surura Jean / Minister Of Home Affairs (2012/90450)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Monjurul Haque / Minister Of Home Affairs (5132/12)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Ndangi Marray / Minister Of Home Affairs (12/10886)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. George Robert Mitchel / Minister of Home Affairs (12/10884)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Monjurul Haque / Minister of Affairs (5132/12)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Jules Kamayi / Minister of Home Affairs (12/10883)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Jileka Abrdo / Minister of Home Affairs (12/10880)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Lopiso Limono / Minister of Home Affairs (12/10889)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Ubedi Benneth & 28 others / Minister of Home Affairs 2 others (10499/12)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Chibuzo Ejikonye / Minister of Home Affairs (12/11065)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Chen Wen Qui and Gamn Xiong / Minister of Home Affairs (12/11068)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
  1. Wankume Matendeka Rael / Minister of Home Affairs (12/11067)
/ Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum