April 2016 doc.: IEEE 802.11-16/0272r5
IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs
Date: 2016-04-19
Author(s):
Name / Affiliation / Address / Phone / email
Hitoshi Morioka / SRC Software / Fukuoka JAPAN /
On
Tuesday February 16th, 2016
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed)
1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (SRC Software)
1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.5. Ping Fang (Huawei)
1.6. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm)
1.7. Xiaofei Wang (InterDigital)
1.8. George Calcev (Huawei)
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:06.
3. Agenda 11-16/0271r0.
3.1. No objections.
4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
4.1. No claims.
5. Editor's report
5.1. Approved resolutions are implemented.
5.2. Modifying according to REVmc D5.0.
5.3. It will be done in this week
6. Internal review
6.1. Vice Chair requested to review D7.0 when available.
6.2. It is basically assigned to the person who provided the resolution.
7. Adjourned at 10:14.
Tuesday March 1st, 2016
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed)
1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (SRC Software)
1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.5. Ping Fang (Huawei)
1.6. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm)
1.7. Xiaofei Wang (InterDigital)
1.8. George Calcev (Huawei)
1.9. Jouni Malinen (Qualcomm)
1.10. Peter Yee (NSA/IAD)
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:05.
3. Agenda 11-16/0271r0.
3.1. No objections.
4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
4.1. No claims.
5. Editor's report
5.1. D6.4 is now at the members’ area.
5.2. D6.4 is based on REVmc5.0.
5.3. Editor asked to verify the draft.
6. Call for Volunteer to Review the Draft
6.1. The provider of the resolutions will be assigned to review the draft by this Saturday.
6.2. If some mis-implementations are found, e-mail to Lee, Marc and Hiroshi.
6.3. We plan to start recirculation on next Tuesday.
6.4. Modification from D6.4 to D7.0 takes maximum 2days by the editor.
6.5. If no controversial topics, next telco will be cancelled.
6.6. Recirculation takes 15 days.
6.7. 11-15/1196r32 is the latest comment spreadsheet.
6.8. If someone not in the sponsor pool like to comment, send comments to the chair.
7. Adjourned at 10:24.
Tuesday March 8th, 2016
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Hitoshi Morioka (SRC Software)
1.3. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.4. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm)
1.5. Jouni Malinen (Qualcomm)
1.6. Peter Yee (NSA/IAD)
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:07.
3. Agenda 11-16/0271r1.
3.1. No objections.
4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
4.1. No claims.
5. Editor's report
5.1. Required correction will start tomorrow.
5.2. D7.0 will be available in this week.
5.3. The chair asked the editor to finish work before Friday.
5.3.1. The editor agreed.
5.4. Recirculation SB will start by Friday.
6. CRC teleconference will be resumed on 29th March.
7. Adjourned at 10:13.
Tuesday April 5th, 2016
10:00ET
1. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:05.
2. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
2.1. No claims.
3. Agenda 11-16/0271r1.
3.1. Approved.
4. Comment Resolutions
4.1. Resolution to editorial comments from TGai SB 1st recirc 11-16/0510r0 Ping Fang (Huawei)
4.1.1. Note: unless otherwise stated, the proposed resolutions are according to 11-16/0510r0.
4.1.2. CID20043
4.1.2.1. Revised.
4.1.2.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.3. CID20078
4.1.3.1. Accept.
4.1.3.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.4. CID20032
4.1.4.1. Accept.
4.1.4.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.5. CID20033
4.1.5.1. Revised.
4.1.5.2. Ready for motion once the comment "further discussion" is deleted from the resolution.
4.1.6. CID20038
4.1.6.1. Accept.
4.1.6.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.7. CID20023
4.1.7.1. Accept.
4.1.7.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.8. CID20022
4.1.8.1. Accept.
4.1.8.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.9. CID20039, 20042, 20044, 20043, 20041
4.1.9.1. revised -- change all instances of "shall be deemed" to "is deemed" throughout the TGai D7.0 draft.
4.1.9.2. discussion: removing the "shall" might not be right even though the group agrees that the language is not optimal
4.1.9.3. Reassign to: Jouni / Dan
4.1.10. CID20058
4.1.10.1. Accept.
4.1.10.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.11. CID20061
4.1.11.1. Revised.
4.1.11.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.12. CID20070
4.1.12.1. Accept.
4.1.12.2. Ready for motion.
4.1.13. CID20002
4.1.13.1. Deffered.
4.1.13.2. an ANA request has been issued
4.1.13.3. will be revisited as a revised once we have the ANA number
4.1.14. CID20013
4.1.14.1. discussion: reference appears in a normative clause. It is not part of a "note" in this clause.
4.1.14.2. The "for example" quoted in the comment is to be read as you have the option of implementing it but if implementing, the reference has to be fully understood.
4.1.14.3. Agreed resolution: REJECT: the RFC 3315 needs to be understood to implement the standard.
4.1.15. discussion of submission to be continued during next call.
4.1.16. CID20107
4.1.16.1. Discussed.
4.1.16.2. Reject.
4.1.16.3. Ready for motion.
4.1.17. CID20108 and 20113
4.1.17.1. Reassigned to Jouni.
5. Adjourned at 11:30.
Tuesday April 12th, 2016
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Marc Emmelmann (self)
1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (SRC Software)
1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.5. Ping Fang (Huawei)
1.6. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm)
1.7. Jouni Malinen (Qualcomm)
1.8. Xiaofei Wang (InterDigital)
1.9. Peter Khoury (Ruckus Wireless)
1.10. Jae Seung Lee (ETRI)
1.11. Jon Rosdahl (CSR-Qualcomm)
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:05.
3. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
3.1. No claims.
4. Agenda 11-16/0271r1.
4.1. Approved.
5. Comment Resolutions
5.1. Status report Marc Emmelmann
5.1.1. CIDs are assigned in the latest xls.
5.1.2. Peter Yee requested to take SIV related comments.
5.1.2.1. We should decide whether to reject the comments or back to GCM by face-to-face meeting.
5.2. Motion #325
5.2.1. Move to approve the comment resolutions as contained in the “2016-04-05-teclo” tab of 11-16-0505r1.
5.2.2. Moved: Jouni Malinen
5.2.3. Seconded: Lee Armstrong
5.2.4. Result: 7/0/1
5.2.5. Motion passes.
5.3. Comment DB Marc Emmelmann
5.3.1. CID20014
5.3.1.1. Assigned to Dan Harkins.
5.4. Resolution to editorial comments from TGai SB 1st recirc 11-16/0510r1 Ping Fang (Huawei)
5.4.1. CID20003
5.4.1.1. Revised.
5.4.1.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.2. CID20004
5.4.2.1. Accept.
5.4.2.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.3. CID20005
5.4.3.1. Revised.
5.4.3.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.4. CID20006
5.4.4.1. Revised.
5.4.4.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.5. CID20008
5.4.5.1. Accept.
5.4.5.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.6. CID20027
5.4.6.1. Accept.
5.4.6.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.7. CID20012
5.4.7.1. Reject.
5.4.7.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.8. CID20016
5.4.8.1. Accept.
5.4.8.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.9. CID20017
5.4.9.1. Accept.
5.4.9.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.10. CID20018
5.4.10.1. Accept.
5.4.10.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.11. CID20019
5.4.11.1. Accept.
5.4.11.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.12. CID20020
5.4.12.1. Accept.
5.4.12.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.13. CID20021
5.4.13.1. Revised.
5.4.13.2. Replace “shall be” with “is”.
5.4.13.3. Ready for motion.
5.4.14. CID20010
5.4.14.1. Accept.
5.4.14.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.15. CID20153
5.4.15.1. Revised.
5.4.15.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.16. CID20077
5.4.16.1. Revised.
5.4.16.2. Add ‘Change “6” to “5” at P61L52.’
5.4.16.3. Ready for motion.
5.4.17. CID20141
5.4.17.1. Accept.
5.4.17.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.18. CID20143
5.4.18.1. Accept.
5.4.18.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.19. CID20144
5.4.19.1. Accept.
5.4.19.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.20. CID20147
5.4.20.1. Accept.
5.4.20.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.21. CID20125
5.4.21.1. Revised.
5.4.21.2. Deferred until ANA assignment.
5.4.22. CID20149
5.4.22.1. Accept.
5.4.22.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.23. CID20123
5.4.23.1. Revised.
5.4.23.2. Deferred until ANA assignment.
5.4.24. CID20154
5.4.24.1. Accept.
5.4.24.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.25. CID20155
5.4.25.1. Accept.
5.4.25.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.26. CID20156
5.4.26.1. Accept.
5.4.26.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.27. CID20158
5.4.27.1. Accept.
5.4.27.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.28. CID20163
5.4.28.1. Revised.
5.4.28.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.29. CID20164
5.4.29.1. Accept.
5.4.29.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.30. CID20148
5.4.30.1. Accept.
5.4.30.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.31. CID20102
5.4.31.1. Accept.
5.4.31.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.32. CID20086
5.4.32.1. Reject.
5.4.32.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.33. CID20087
5.4.33.1. Reject.
5.4.33.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.34. CID20088
5.4.34.1. Reject.
5.4.34.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.35. CID20091
5.4.35.1. Revised.
5.4.35.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.36. CID20096
5.4.36.1. Accept.
5.4.36.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.37. CID20139
5.4.37.1. Reject.
5.4.37.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.38. CID20098
5.4.38.1. Accept.
5.4.38.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.39. CID20166
5.4.39.1. Accept.
5.4.39.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.40. CID20103
5.4.40.1. Accept.
5.4.40.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.41. CID20104
5.4.41.1. Accept.
5.4.41.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.42. CID20106
5.4.42.1. Accept.
5.4.42.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.43. CID20111
5.4.43.1. Reject.
5.4.43.2. moving from D6.0 to D7.0 changed the order column and the renumbering in that column relfected the new order. Due to readability the location of the rows will not be moved into place until the editorial process. Editorial instructions are given as follows: note that when an “Order” number has changed, the row was not moved to the position it will be in the final document, this is to avoid having everything in these rows being either a strikethrough or underline which would make it very difficult for the reader to know what is changing besides the order.
5.4.43.3. Ready for motion.
5.4.44. CID20114
5.4.44.1. Accept.
5.4.44.2. Ready for motion.
5.4.45. CID20121
5.4.45.1. Accept.
5.4.45.2. Deferred until ANA assignment.
5.4.46. CID20097
5.4.46.1. Accept.
5.4.46.2. Ready for motion.
6. If anyone intend to handle specific CIDs, please send a request to the reflector.
7. Adjourned at 11:32.
Minutes page 1 Hitoshi Morioka, SRC Software